Thursday, February 28, 2013
The Braindead Megaphone
I think that through the metaphor of the dinner party and the person with the megaphone, we see that Saunders is trying to represent the media and its profound affect on the community. In the dinner party scene, it is not the most intelligent or most articulate person who affects the way that the guests think or hold conversations, but it is the person who has the loud megaphone that shapes their thoughts. Even without consciously realizing it, the people will begin talking about the weather if the person with the megaphone does. This is a parallel to media and how it's proliferated or "loud" presence morphs the way that we think about certain issues, or not think about certain issues. Saunders explains in part 4 that the media fails to address important issues, and instead focuses hours and hours on the exciting, but insignificant events, like the OJ Simpson trial. Therefore, we as the guests at the dinner table will focus our time more on the insignificant cases like the OJ Simpson trial and ignore the other, more pressing problems in the world, like the War in Iraq.
The Braindead Megaphone
In George Saunders' essay The Braindead Megaphone, he writes of a person who is not necessarily intelligent but manages to gain the attention of even the most successful people in a room. Slowly but surely, the party goers begin to agree and the speaker and manages to get them to agree with him because he possesses a megaphone. What makes the story scarier as it goes along is that the speaker does not think through their words before they speak them so the audience is potentially being fed the wrong information. After a while, I came to realize that George Saunders was not just speaking of a random guy with a megaphone but the megaphone stood for much more than that. In the end, I started seeing the person with the megaphone as a politician trying to convince their citizens that their stance on an issue was the right one. And whether the people wanted to listen or not, they were always bombarded with news of the latest stance the politician took. Many people would understand this especially after the recent presidential election we had where a person could not change to a random television channel without hearing something about the ongoing campaign.
Wednesday, February 27, 2013
The Megaphone
I think that Saunders uses the megaphone to represent the
mass media. Much like the megaphone man, today’s news stories have evolved with
the intention of shocking and grabbing the public’s attention. Instead of the ‘dinner
party’ conversations of different flavors and carefully crafted arguments, the one-sided
media brings down the level of discourse. The loudest opinion is the one that
people are most inclined to listen to and react to. In fact, many talk programs are simply reactionary to other more dominant news shows; their programming
serves to reiterate, debate, and ultimately agree with the “loudest”
source. I think the dinner party analogy
is very clever because he makes the function of the megaphone very clear.
In section 7, Saunders goes on to say that the megaphone is draws
its life-force from attention. He states that “today we are led into the arena
of public debate by seers whose main gift is their ability to compel people to
continue to watch them” (Saunders, 245). This fits perfectly into the idea that
the megaphone is the media; it would be unable to survive and lose its validity
entirely if no one watched it. But yet, the mass media continues to entice the
public with shocking, offensive headlines and flashy half-truths. And because
it’s the loudest voice, we are compelled to react and feed the fire.
Saunders-megaphone
The party setting is arbitrary along with the topics of discussion, but the megaphone has a purpose. This is apparent from the start of the essay it is easy to tell even though Saunders isn't being direct. He writes about a "megaphone" without spelling out exactly what he means, just as in real life, people may not be aware of the "megaphone". The megaphone in the essay is used by someone who may not be the most knowledgeable or have the best opinions, but others are forced to listen due to their volume and overpowering voice. As the guests at the party listen, they begin to discuss the same topics and find themselves agreeing with the holder of the megaphone.
The megaphone is a metaphor for sources that we believe to be voices of authority in our country such as the government or news stations. Saunders expresses strongly that they shouldnt always be trusted despite our expectation of them to deliver the truth to us.
The megaphone is a metaphor for sources that we believe to be voices of authority in our country such as the government or news stations. Saunders expresses strongly that they shouldnt always be trusted despite our expectation of them to deliver the truth to us.
The Braindead Megaphone
At the beginning of Saunder's essay, I think he gives a pretty clear idea of what the megaphone represents, and I agree with this idea. The thought that most forms of media, the news on TV in particular, influence are minds greatly and have an affect on how we think. Likewise, when carefully planned by newsrooms or news directors or who ever really runs the show (no pun intended) at a news channel, this form of media can be used to manipulate what and how people think- to an extent. Where I disagree with George when he starts implying how gullible most people are and how easily people can be manipulated. I believe most people when the watch the news can tell what is just filler stories and what really happens at breaking news stories.
Comparing the megaphone in the first few sections to the last few sections, I find a difference in their representations. Saunders then switches to how the manipulated mind responded to 9/11 and invaded Iraq, all without proper planning. I disagree with this, every military decision is well thought out before action, and when they are poor decisions, the population can see through them and not blindly agree.
Comparing the megaphone in the first few sections to the last few sections, I find a difference in their representations. Saunders then switches to how the manipulated mind responded to 9/11 and invaded Iraq, all without proper planning. I disagree with this, every military decision is well thought out before action, and when they are poor decisions, the population can see through them and not blindly agree.
Meaning of the Megaphone
The megaphone in George Saunders' essay "The Braindead Megaphone" is a metaphor for the censorship and control that the government and the media have over the general population. A great example of an extreme case of this is North Korea. The people there are told lies on a daily basis, but they believe them all because the source of the lies is somebody that they believe has all of the answers. They only hear what he says, and he drowns out what everybody else is thinking or saying. When Saunders says, "He has, in effect, put an intelligence ceiling on the party" it relates to how when a government forces it's ideas onto it's people, it restricts how intelligent they can be. They lose the ability to think for themselves and to question the world around them.
Saunders mentions the media in section five, and he says that they way they present the news lessens the viewers ability to communicate and think freely. He says that the news anchor will read some story, but the story is pointless and common sense, but the way that they read it makes it seem like the person watching has learned something new. The viewer then takes this "knowledge" and feels that they should do the same thing, because this figure on television has done it. They restrict a person's ability to have an intelligent conversation and instead they just comment on things that are easily observed. This in a way is placing an intelligence-ceiling on these people.
Saunders mentions the media in section five, and he says that they way they present the news lessens the viewers ability to communicate and think freely. He says that the news anchor will read some story, but the story is pointless and common sense, but the way that they read it makes it seem like the person watching has learned something new. The viewer then takes this "knowledge" and feels that they should do the same thing, because this figure on television has done it. They restrict a person's ability to have an intelligent conversation and instead they just comment on things that are easily observed. This in a way is placing an intelligence-ceiling on these people.
Tuesday, February 26, 2013
Meaning of the Megaphone
As I was reading The Braindead Megaphone by George Saunders I quickly realized that the focus of this essay was not on a real megaphone. The megaphone is being used as a metaphor which could be perceived as may different things. I think one of the most widely recognized things that the megaphone could be is the government or some type of ruling power. In this essay the megaphone is perceived as something that is powerful and in control, capturing people's attention. I feel that this is what the government does. Whether people in society agree with the decisions that the government is making or not, they always find themselves listening to the news or some time of publication where the government is reaching out to the community.
Saunders even makes a connection to the government in this essay. He quickly touches upon the subject of war. In section 4 of this essay Saunders refers to the people as "sitting ducks." He believes that people just sit around and take orders from the megaphone which in this case is the government. Although looking at society, this may seem true, I think that there is a a lot more to it. People see the megaphone as a leader, so we do follow them, but also, we trust them. We follow them because we believe that they are making a decision which will better us. We do not follow because we have nothing better to do or because we do not have enough knowledge to lead ourselves. We are doing what we feel is right. The people that are apart of the government are people that a majority of the community has thought would be best to make decisions for them, therefore we follow their beliefs.
Saunders even makes a connection to the government in this essay. He quickly touches upon the subject of war. In section 4 of this essay Saunders refers to the people as "sitting ducks." He believes that people just sit around and take orders from the megaphone which in this case is the government. Although looking at society, this may seem true, I think that there is a a lot more to it. People see the megaphone as a leader, so we do follow them, but also, we trust them. We follow them because we believe that they are making a decision which will better us. We do not follow because we have nothing better to do or because we do not have enough knowledge to lead ourselves. We are doing what we feel is right. The people that are apart of the government are people that a majority of the community has thought would be best to make decisions for them, therefore we follow their beliefs.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)